Home > News > The Best Pizza in Sheffield you absolutely must try

The Best Pizza in Sheffield you absolutely must try

Best Pizza in Sheffield Guide

The Best Pizza in Sheffield you absolutely must try

If there’s one thing society *almost* entirely agrees on, I would suggest that it’s pizza. Its versatility as a celebration meal, social food or late-night tummy filler means there’s pretty much no situation that can’t be improved by our Italian friend’s excellent creation.

However, there’s no need to jet off to Italy for your next Margherita mouthful as Sheffield has got you thoroughly covered. Grab your wallet and your pizza-loving friends, because we’re off on a pizza-crawl around the seven hills of Sheffield.


It’s pretty much impossible to think about pizza in Sheffield without Proove coming to mind. A true Sheffield favourite established in Broomhill, Proove is inspired by the ‘fuss-free’ attitude to dining, meaning quality is paramount but the atmosphere is relaxed and friendly so everyone can enjoy the delights of traditional wood-fired pizza. With ingredients sourced from Italy and a strong heart for delicious pizza, you can be sure that every mouthful will live up to expectations. What’s more, you can get them to deliver if you feel like staying in. (Proove, featured in this article’s cover).

261 Fulwood Rd, Sheffield S10 3BD – 0114 294 5185

Craft and Dough Sheffield New Kelham Bar

Craft and Dough

For a fresh, artisan pizza paired with selected craft beers from local and national breweries, look no further than Craft and Dough. With two locations, one in Kelham Island and one on Campo Lane, you don’t have to travel far to experience their stylish wooden and white tile interiors and quality pizza goodness. Don’t forget to book onto one of their pizza making classes, though their pizzas be mighty fine they are willing to share their secrets. Perfect for veggies, vegans and gluten-free as well. Find them on Deliveroo if getting out ain’t your thing.

44 Campo Lane, Sheffield, S1 2EG – 0114 272 2150
1A Kelham Square, Kelham Island, Sheffield, S3 8SD – 0114 276 2803

Silversmiths Bottomless Brunch Sheffield

Nether Edge Pizza

Nether Edge Pizza Company started off as a family run street food vendor cooking up tasty pizzas around Sheffield. They later expanded to a post at the popular Peddler Market, and have recently set up shop on Abbeydale Road. As winners of the Exposed Award for Best Street Food Vendor in 2018, they offer a pretty mean pizza capable of inducing rumbly tummies from pictures alone. Big on the Sheffield food scene these are not ones to miss, so if you can’t make it to the restaurant, get delivery on Uber Eats or Deliveroo. Insider tip – don’t miss their delicious wood-fired bagels.

144 Abbeydale Rd, Sheffield S7 1FF – 0114 250 8037

Picture House Social Pizza

Picture House Social

If you’re looking for the perfect place to kick back and relax after a long day’s work, Picture House Social won’t disappoint. Built in the basement of the old picture house along Abbeydale Road, Picture House Social provides a space to grab an award-winning cocktail, play a little ping-pong or see a gig, chill on the terrace, or, most importantly, munch on a Neapolitan style pizza. They source ingredients from Italy, and the dough is proved for a minimum of 36 hours before the pizzas are hand stretched and made fresh to order. Delish.

383 Abbeydale Road, Nether Edge, Sheffield, S7 1FS – 0114 258 1690

Silversmiths Sunday Lunch | 3-Courses & a Drink

Forge Bakehouse

Since their opening back in 2012, Forge Bakehouse have been serving the good people of Sheffield with quality food made from scratch. When you eat at Forge Bakehouse, you can be sure that you’re not feeding yourself with additives or fast food, and they have a commitment to reducing waste and take time over each batch or brew to make everything perfect. Forge Bakehouse have been included in this list because although pizza doesn’t feature on their regular menu, it’s worth watching out for their pop-up sourdough pizza events.

302 Abbeydale Road, Sheffield, S7 1FL – 0114 258 8987

Napoli Centro Sheffield Pizza

Napoli Centro

Napoli Centro are new to Sheffield’s food scene, but already cooking up a storm with their delicious pizzas. With a traditional Italian menu combined with a modern twist, Napoli Centro is the new place to be. Eat in with Negroni in hand or check them out on Deliveroo for pizza heaven at home.

343 Glossop Rd, Sheffield S10 2HP – 01142700050

Gigi’s Cucina Sheffield Exterior

Gigi’s Cucina

Gigi’s Cucina was born out of Gigi’s Italian heritage and belief that good food shouldn’t have to cost the earth. Combining fresh local ingredients with contemporary cooking, Gigi’s pizza maintains Italian authenticity in every slice. Dine feeling relaxed in the family-run establishment with a quality glass of wine in hand.

139-141 Oakbrook Rd, Sheffield S11 7EB – 0114 327 4600

 The Florentine

The Florentine offers a friendly but sophisticated pub environment for pizza lovers. They strive to offer a ‘home-from-home’ atmosphere that doesn’t shy away from excellence, so diners can feel pampered with every sip and every mouthful. With their very own dough recipe, wood-fired oven and the finest toppings, have no doubt that you’ll enjoy your pizza at The Florentine.

Tapton Park Rd, Sheffield S10 3FG – 0114 230 8692

Porter Pizza Sheffield Vegan special

Porter Pizza Company

The Porter Pizza Company had a goal to bring a taste of Italy home to Sheffield, and since 2015 they have achieved just that. Championing traditional ingredients and methods, such as hand stretching the dough, their pizzas are as tasty as they come. Cosy up next to the wood fire oven in their snuggly restaurant and treat yourself to Italian goodness. Don’t forget that you can order through Deliveroo for those days the sofa is calling.

410 Sharrow Vale Road, Sheffield, S11 8ZP – 0114 267 6672

Baked in Brick Sheffield Pizza Kommune Food Hall

Baked in Brick at Kommune

Baked in Brick, European and British street food award winners, have made their way over to Sheffield to set up shop in Kommune, Sheffield’s new food hall. Baked in Brick was born three years ago out of a hand-built pizza oven and a converted Mini Cooper. Passion is not lacking in this British venture, meaning their pizzas are a firm favourite and definitely worth checking out.

Kommune, Castle House, Angel Street, Sheffield


Best Bottomless Brunch in Sheffield

Coniston Spa Yorkshire Dales Retreat

Coniston Cold, Skipton BD23 4EA
  • Set in the tranquil surroundings of The Coniston Estate
  • Award-winning multi-million-pound spa facilities
  • SAVE up to 15%
From  £58.00 Read More Select options
Coniston Cold, Skipton BD23 4EA

Cocktail Masterclass at Liquor Studio, Leeds

156a Lower Briggate, Leeds LS1 6LY
  • Become a master of mixing, muddling and shaking up cocktails at this interactive experience.
  • SAVE 15%
£39.95 £33.95 Save 15% £39.95 15% OFF Read More Book ticket
156a Lower Briggate, Leeds LS1 6LY

No.1 GuestHouse York Afternoon Tea

1 Clifton, York YO30 6AA
  • Insta-worthy Grade II listed townhouse hotel
  • Close to York’s iconic Minster
  • SAVE 21%
£38.00 £30.00 Save 21% £38 21% OFF Read More Add to cart
1 Clifton, York YO30 6AA

Angelica & Crafthouse Leeds Sparkling Afternoon Tea

  • Beautiful rooftop city centre restaurant
  • Enjoy a stunning afternoon tea with a glass of prosecco
  • SAVE 23%
£36.25 £28.00 Save 23% £36.25 23% OFF Read More Add to cart

Afternoon Tea for Two at Goldsborough Hall

Goldsborough Hall, Church St, Knaresborough HG5 8NR
  • Magnificent stately home near Harrogate
  • Michelin recommended dining
  • SAVE 13%
£80.00 £70.00 Save 13% £80 13% OFF Read More Add to cart
Goldsborough Hall, Church St, Knaresborough HG5 8NR

Masons of Yorkshire Gin Distillery Tour with Tastings

Northallerton, DL7 9EE
  • Guided tour and tasting experience inside multi-award-winning distillery
  • Yorkshire’s first gin distillery
  • SAVE 10%
£25.00 £22.50 Save 10% £25.00 10% OFF Read More Book ticket
Northallerton, DL7 9EE

Written by

Jemima Parsons


Tags and Categories

Join our Foodie Community

Keep up to date with the latest news, reviews, foodie events and exclusive offers

By subscribing I agree to Yorkshire Food Guide’s T&Cs and Privacy Policy